Choose Linear for dedicated issue planning and product cycles; choose GitHub Issues when work needs to stay close to repositories and pull requests. Test both on one real project before switching.

Workflow sources checked November 13, 2026. The capabilities below come from official documentation. The selection advice and trial are our suggested evaluation, not results from testing either product. Confirm current plan access and pricing separately before paying.

Quick Decision

  • Start with Linear when planning is the bottleneck. Projects group issues around an outcome or planned completion date and can involve multiple teams. Cycles organize work into recurring time periods; they are not release deadlines. Trial question: can a product lead see the feature scope and the team's current work without maintaining another status sheet?
  • Start with GitHub Issues when the code handoff is the bottleneck. Issues track bugs, ideas and tasks in repositories, with assignees, labels, milestones and links to pull requests. Closing keywords in a pull request description link and close the associated issue when the pull request targets and merges into the repository's default branch. Trial question: can a reviewer follow the report through to the proposed fix and its completion?
  • Add GitHub Projects when Issues need a planning view. Projects provide tables, boards and roadmaps containing issues and pull requests, with custom fields and saved views. Changes to linked issue information sync between the project and issue. Trial question: can a stakeholder understand the next milestone from a saved view without visiting each repository?

GitHub Projects complements Issues in this comparison. Evaluate the combined workflow against Linear, rather than treating Projects as a separate fallback tracker. If you keep Linear alongside GitHub, choose one place for status and ownership and test how the other system reflects it before importing a backlog.

The Same Planning Tasks, Side by Side

TaskLinearGitHub Issues plus Projects
Break a larger issue into tasksParent and sub-issues, with optional team-level parent and sub-issue auto-close settings.Nested sub-issues, with parent and progress information available in Projects.
Plan repeating work periodsCycles, once enabled for a team, follow a repeating schedule, and Linear creates upcoming cycles automatically.Iteration fields associate project items with repeating time blocks, including breaks.
Organize a featureProjects group issues around an outcome or completion date, with a lead, milestones and documents.Projects organize issues and pull requests with custom fields, tables, boards and roadmaps.
Save a focused viewLinear projects can have named, filtered issue views, such as bugs or in-progress work.GitHub Projects can save views that filter, sort, slice and group issues and pull requests.

Linear vs GitHub Projects: What You Configure

A Linear issue belongs to one project at a time, while the project can span teams. Its project overview holds the description, resources and milestones; team and workspace project pages offer timeline views. GitHub Projects instead provides a configurable planning surface over issues and pull requests, with custom date, priority and iteration fields. GitHub also supports project status updates, start dates and target dates.

Linear's cycle documentation describes automatic rollover of unfinished work, with exceptions for issues moved to backlog, triage, canceled or completed during cooldown. GitHub's iteration documentation describes grouping a view by iteration and bulk-moving its items to another iteration. That documented move is a user action, not a promise of automatic rollover. In the trial, leave one task unfinished and check the next period's scope before treating the two workflows as interchangeable.

Pull Requests: Linking Is Not Always Closing

In GitHub, a description such as Fixes #123 uses a closing keyword. The linking documentation says those keywords are ignored when the pull request targets a non-default branch: they create no link and the merge has no effect on the issue. Test the branch your team actually merges into, not only a sandbox's default.

Linear's GitHub integration distinguishes closing words such as Fixes ENG-123, non-closing words such as Refs ENG-123, and relation words such as Related to ENG-123. Closing links follow the team's mapped workflow, including its configured merge status. Non-closing links can trigger other status changes but not the merge-status change; relation links make no status changes. Teams can also configure rules for particular target branches. A linked pull request therefore does not, by itself, establish that an issue will become Done.

Keeping Both: Sync and Migration Limits

Linear's GitHub integration supports one-way or two-way issue sync, but it only syncs newly created issues; existing GitHub issues require import. Several repositories can feed one Linear team one-way, but only one repository can be set to two-way sync at a time, and Linear's feature table lists issue sync as unavailable for GitHub Enterprise Server. It explicitly excludes custom statuses set at the GitHub Project level from status sync. Comments sync through the linked thread in Linear, not every comment elsewhere in the Linear issue. If stakeholders rely on a Project's custom status, test that field separately rather than assuming the two trackers show the same state.

Linear's import guide requires a workspace admin to start imports and warns that concepts without a good match may not import. Its export documentation says workspace admins (only owners on Enterprise plans) can export workspace issue data as CSV, with fields including descriptions, assignees, cycles and parent issues, but says CSV exports do not include attachment files. Attachment links may remain in descriptions. An exported issue list is therefore not proof that the original context can be reconstructed in another tracker.

One Fictional Workflow to Try in Both

Use a small private sandbox with invented data: a checkout form accepts an invalid address, a fix needs review, and a follow-up improvement belongs to the next milestone. Do not copy customer details into the trial.

  1. Capture the report. Create one issue with the same reproduction steps, expected behavior and owner. Ask a teammate to find what needs doing from the issue alone. Record any missing context.
  2. Plan the work. In Linear, group the fix and follow-up in a project and place the current work in a cycle. In GitHub, add the issues to a Project with status and a target-date or iteration field. Keep the scope the same and note how much configuration each route needs.
  3. Hand off to code review. Link a sandbox pull request to the issue. GitHub's documented closing-keyword behavior is one option; for Linear, check the chosen GitHub integration and its settings before assuming a merge updates status. Record whether the reviewer can return to the original report.
  4. Show progress to a non-developer. Ask a teammate to identify the owner, current status and remaining work from the project view. Record extra navigation or explanations needed. Test with the permissions that teammate would actually have.
  5. Close and recover the context. Complete the fix, leave the follow-up open and find the original discussion again. Check the current export documentation and try an available export on this small dataset; do not assume comments, attachments or every relationship survive it.

Write down setup time, duplicate status edits, unclear handoffs and any unavailable feature. These are observations to collect, not scores we have assigned. A shorter trial can be enough if it exposes the bottleneck; a three-week subscription is not required to follow this exercise.

What to Check Before Switching

The planning views do not establish plan entitlements, access for external collaborators or migration completeness. Check those against the exact workspace and plan you would use. Estimate seats and integration maintenance for the people who create work and the people who only review it. For Linear plan and free-plan details, see ToolPick's Linear record and confirm current terms on Linear's official pricing page. GitHub also has a ToolPick record with plan information; no prices are compared here.

Move a small sample first. Verify issue descriptions, owners, comments, attachments, labels and links individually. If a field cannot transfer, decide where its history will stay and who maintains the link. Keep the original backlog available until the team can recover the context it needs.

Final Recommendation

Choose Linear if its project and cycle workflow removes a repeated planning problem in your trial. Choose GitHub Issues plus Projects if the repository-to-review workflow covers planning without another status system. Keep both only when each has a named purpose and the handoff works with your actual permissions and integrations.

Official Workflow Sources